And talk about a strong opener: “Box Of Rain” is a fully fleshed-out arrangement, with acoustic guitar, Clarence White-flavored leads, harmonies, piano, bass and both drummers in a busy mix, capped by a lead vocal by Phil Lesh. It really is one of their best tracks, especially when heard in context with the two songs that come next. “Friend Of The Devil” is the one all guitar players try to learn, with its descending riff in G, but what we hear now is the high-speed mandolin, contributed by Garcia buddy David Grisman. (We also can’t help singing the first verse of “Kiss Me Deadly” along with that riff. Mostly because we don’t know the rest of “Kiss Me Deadly”.) “Sugar Magnolia”, with Jerry playing pedal steel like nobody else, is just as much of a quintessential Dead tune, and always seems longer than it really is. “Operator” is Pigpen’s contribution to both the album and the genre of songs that take place on a telephone. “Candyman” sounds most like the last album, being another slow sad lope, and loaded with lots of folk song references.
Any Deadhead worth his or her salt will immediately swoon and sway to “Ripple”, and join in the celestial choir finishing the tune with “da da da”s. On the record it’s a quick segue to “Brokedown Palace”, which almost seems like a natural part two, a honky tonk piano adding to the atmosphere. Something of a sore thumb is “Till The Morning Comes”, mostly because we far prefer Neil Young’s shorter song of a similar title from the same year. There’s something a little sinister about declaring “you’re my woman now” and demanding that she make herself easy. “Attics Of My Life” provides a wide palette to prove how much they’d progressed on their harmonies, but just like the last album started and finished strong, so does this with “Truckin’”, which has more drug references to make the kids giggle, and the source of any mention of a long, strange trip.
To continue our Beatles insight above, while that band spent the next three years in the studio, the Dead took the opposite route, and wouldn’t release another studio album of new material for three years. They almost didn’t have to, since they proved themselves so well with both Workingman’s Dead and American Beauty. This album completes the one-two punch, and belongs in the other side of a Maxell 90 with its brother. (Live versions, most from before the album was released, all needing a lot of work on harmonies, fill up the expanded disc, along with edited single versions of “Truckin’” and “Ripple”. The eventual 50th Anniversary Deluxe Edition kept with the program by adding another show from three days before the one on the bonus discs in the Workingman’s Dead anniversary set. And just as with that release, a few hours of demos and alternate takes were released digitally as American Beauty: The Angel’s Share.)
Grateful Dead American Beauty (1970)—4
2003 CD reissue: same as 1970, plus 8 extra tracks
2020 50th Anniversary Deluxe Edition: same as 1970, plus 23 extra tracks
While I don’t agree that it makes a huge jump like the one from “Rubber Soul” to “Revolver”, I do agree that it’s a better album than the previous one. For one thing, there’s more variety, thanks to Phil and Bob contributing songs and lead vocals. Of course, that’s also means that Pigpen gets one, too, unfortunately. I just don’t like the guy’s voice, sorry! The other letdown for me is “Brokedown Palace”, mainly because I can never remember it after the album stops playing.
ReplyDeleteOtherwise, the album is chockfull is of classics. “Box of Rain” and “Ripple” are two of the most moving, spiritual pieces that the band ever recorded. On the other end of the spectrum, there’s the creepy “Candyman”. “Till the Morning Comes” is a pop throwback (specifically, to “The Golden Road”) and seems like an obvious single to me. “Attics of My Life” proves that they carried their CSN emulation attempts a bit too far this time, especially live. They don’t quite have the voices for this. It would have been interesting to hear CSN cover it!
Then, there’s “Truckin ‘”, the only Grateful Dead song that I heard before college, done by a cover band. I was fascinated by it. (Growing up in N.H. during the first half of the 70’s sucked. There was only one FM station, playing “Beautiful Music” – Lord save us. The Dead got nowhere near AM Top 40 during this period, of course). The single mix, at least, contains different guitar parts. However, whoever edited the mono single version of “Ripple” cut out the verse with “Let it be known there is a fountain/that was not made by the hands of men”. A travesty! That may be the single best couplet Hunter ever wrote.
As for the live bonus tracks, I can take them or leave them. But couldn’t they have found a better performance of “Truckin’ “ from this era? The mix is in atrocious mono, and the band sounds rather sloppy. Oh, well, there was always “Europe ‘72”. Plus, I got to hear them do it in 1985, much to my amazement! Thank the Good Lord for Deadheads and their tape recorders!