Rolling Stones 1: England’s Newest Hit Makers

The Rolling Stones are unique among their generation for many reasons, but one of the biggest is that over three decades into the digital era, their catalog is a complete mess. For starters, unlike many of their contemporaries, their CD standard is based not on the original British albums but the American ones. Perhaps we can thank Allen Klein for that; the Stones catalog came out on CD before the Beatles’ did, and it’s remained the same ever since, with few exceptions. (Admittedly, those late-‘80s CDs were a sonic improvement on the “electronically reprocessed for stereo” mixes on the original LPs.) In the new century, the ABKCO-owned catalog was revamped again, with various British albums added to the racks alongside the American ones. Then, when the mono mixes of their ‘60s studio output were boxed up in a set, the five British albums were interspersed with six American albums, which means a couple dozen songs are repeated here and there.

Not that the band itself hasn’t always put the fans first. Since their inception, in America alone they’ve put out exactly 25 studio albums, plus 13 compilations and 10 live albums; that last number doesn’t include the “official bootlegs” they’ve made available for download in recent years. 1980 was the last time a studio album was preceded by another; after that every studio album has been followed by either a live album, a collection, or both. The greed of ABKCO is surpassed only by that of Mick Jagger.

They started out as an R&B band, and it would be several years before they successfully mastered the album format (unlike the Beatles, who defined it, and the Who, who thrived in it, both during the same period). Thanks to record company miscomprehension, the first Stones albums were marketed to the teenybopper crowd, and why not. With the super-hyped title England’s Newest Hit Makers, their American debut was pretty close to their first, self-titled British LP, and therefore nicely shows what they had to offer this early.

Their own writing was neither up to snuff nor particularly encouraged. But as modern blues machines they were turning out quality, if not definitive, versions of “Not Fade Away”, “Route 66” and “I Just Want To Make Love To You” among their covers. That would be young Brian Jones blowing away on most of the harmonica (since Mick hadn’t learned it that well yet) and playing the more complicated slide guitar; it was his band in the first place, as is most obvious here. Of course, the better lifts from Chuck Berry would be Keith the Human Riff himself, and that’s the sound that would be most consistent over the next fifty years. (The wheezy organ on “Now I’ve Got A Witness” is courtesy of Ian Stewart, who always sounded better on piano, and never played anything but major chords.)

Outside of a couple of group-credited tunes, the only Jagger/Richards original here is “Tell Me”, driven by Keith’s 12-string as he mewls along with Mick on the choruses. Even for an album just over half an hour long, this one lasts over four minutes. (Another prize moment: Charlie Watts’ fills following “knock on my door”.) Lovelorn Mick doesn’t sound quite as natural as the horny toad in “I’m A King Bee” and “Walking The Dog”, while the latter does provide stereophonic proof as to why Brian Jones was usually prevented from singing.

Having been (mostly) conceived as an album (as opposed to a bunch of singles or stopgap EPs), England’s Newest Hit Makers is a strong debut, suffering from little record company interference. The production was a little primitive, but Charlie’s drums crackle, and even Bill Wyman knew how to make his bass heard. A good start, and who knew how long they’d last?

The Rolling Stones England’s Newest Hit Makers (1964)—4