Monday, November 25, 2013

Eric Clapton 3: Layla

So much has been written over the years about this album that we hesitate to weigh in. Certainly it’s essential for any fans of the electric guitar; even after everything Eric Clapton accomplished in the ‘60s, Layla was still a new height for his development, both professionally and creatively.

It’s understandably considered a Clapton album—released only three months after his solo debut—but we must remember that Derek and the Dominos were, above all, a band. Clapton and keyboard player Bobby Whitlock collaborated early and often on the album, Bobby’s vocals adding a Sam & Dave-style vibe to the album as a whole. Bassist Carl Radle and drummer Jim Gordon were tight, having played with Delaney & Bonnie (where they met Clapton) and Joe Cocker’s Mad Dogs & Englishmen. All four (along with Dave Mason, seemingly incapable of being in any band for more than a few gigs) worked on George Harrison’s All Things Must Pass, and went off to Florida to record. While there, they crossed paths with the Allman Brothers Band, which is how Duane Allman ended up guesting on the album. (That’s also important to mention: he didn’t play on the whole thing, and only played two shows with the Dominos. He was devoted to his own band and remained so.)

“I Looked Away” is a great opener, and a song that doesn’t get enough attention. All of the elements of the band are introduced here, setting a standard for the four sides. Jim Gordon inverts the snare and kick on “Bell Bottom Blues” in a way no one else do, yet makes it work. “Keep On Growing”, just like “Anyday” on side two, builds a good groove over six and a half minutes, working the guitars and organ nicely against each other. Likewise, “Nobody Knows You When You’re Down And Out” and “Key To The Highway” establish themselves as the modern standard by which these blues standards are known today. If there’s a clunker in the first half, it’s “I Am Yours”, which uses a poetic idea from an earlier century but not as well as the title track, and predicts Clapton’s laid-back style of the ‘70s.

The second half of the album is stellar. “Tell The Truth” finds the stank and stays there, giving Duane plenty of room to soar. “Why Does Love Got To Be So Sad?” builds on a hyper-tense rhythm—with excellent fretwork from Carl Radle—eventually settling into a nice groove for the fade. “Have You Ever Loved A Woman” is another cover, but more fitting with Clapton’s overall theme for the album, that being his infatuation with George Harrison’s wife.

Things absolutely take off on side four. Their epic, keening arrangement of “Little Wing” does to Hendrix’s original what he did to “All Along The Watchtower” (and amazingly, they recorded it before he died). The final cover is the much simpler “It’s Too Late”, which gets its point across much faster than the blues workouts of the other sides. It’s merely a sorbet for the unmistakable riff of “Layla”, a song that’s a classic all its own, but is truly made by Jim Gordon’s gorgeous piano theme (which he stole from Rita Coolidge) over the second half of the track. It is truly one of the finer moments in music. And where can you go from there? Bobby’s solo “Thorn Tree In The Garden” has been compared to “Good Night” following “Revolution 9”, but we think it’s more like having to settle for vanilla ice cream because they ran out of chocolate.

There’s a lot of music on Layla, and the great moments still stand out, even after decades of Classic Rock Radio threatening to kill them off. It’s very possible to make a stellar single LP out of the music here, but that would suggest that the lesser tracks are garbage, which they’re not.

Because of the length, it first appeared as a double CD until the industry caught up to capacity capabilities. It was also the recipient of the first box set devoted to a single album; 1990’s The Layla Sessions served up the album on a single disc, plus a disc of jams with and with the Allman Brothers Band, and another disc of alternate takes. That was for the 20th anniversary; the 40th anniversary brought forth a deluxe edition, with other unreleased tracks, plus songs recorded for their stillborn second album, and the so-called “super deluxe” version, which added an expansion of 1973’s In Concert album to all that. These are all for those with unlimited income; everybody else should stick with the original. On vinyl. Or the single CD, ‘cos it’s convenient.

Derek and the Dominos Layla And Other Assorted Love Songs (1970)—4½
1992 The Layla Sessions: 20th Anniversary Edition: same as 1970, plus 15 extra tracks
2011 40th Anniversary Deluxe Edition: same as 1970, plus 13 extra tracks (Super Deluxe Edition adds another 13 tracks plus DVD)

2 comments:

  1. Ooh yeah. And it's always salutary to remember that Clapton betrayed the overwhelming, heartbreaking passion of his finest song (possibly of rock music's finest song) by turning it into a detestable retirement home clap-along. No other artist has squandered his own heritage so completely, and the fact that he continues to play the song this way shows it wasn't an unfortunate and forgiveable mis-step.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I had never listened to this album the whole way through. Since everybody raves about it, I figured that it was about time. My reaction is, as it is to that other biggie that got airplay in 1971 (the 4th Zeppelin album), is atypical. I think both albums are a bit overrated.

    For one thing, I do wish that there was more variety in the lyrics. I know that I’m probably a minority of one on this, but I can only hear so many songs about desperately wanting a woman that belongs to another man at one time (I admit age might have something to do with that). I suppose that Clapton was SO obsessed that he couldn’t possibly sing or write about anything else at the time. On the other hand, I’d rather hear this stuff than “Wonderful Tonight” (hold nose emoji).

    I also admit that I, for the most part, don’t gravitate towards blues music. I can take it in small doses, but here there are some very big doses. Play “Nobody Knows You When You're Down and Out” and "Have You Ever Loved a Woman?” right in a row. You’ll discover that they’re the same song! If there are any differences in the chords, I can’t discern them. And did “Key to the Highway” need to be almost ten minutes long?

    Of course, what saves what could be totally tedious is the incredible musicianship of everybody involved. Boy, could these guys play. The duetting of Clapton and Whitlock on the vocals is very effective.

    Tom Dowd, the producer, also deserves a huge amount of credit. Although these players were all on the “Eric Clapton” album, the sound that Delaney provided was relatively laid-back. Dowd brought out the power of the band.

    The best cover song is the majestic version of “Little Wing”. The guitars just ring out. As for the originals, I like “I Am Yours” quite a bit. It sounds like he was influenced by his pal George. It also sounds like it could have been on Fleetwood Mac’s “Future Games”, although that had yet to be recorded. Unlike most people, I prefer the more rocking version of “Tell the Truth” from the single. “Anyway” and “Keep on Growing” sound a bit more optimistic than the balance of the album.

    I only ever heard three songs on the radio, besides “Little Wing”. I didn’t know that "Bell Bottom Blues" had been a single . I like the way it soars on the chorus. Another thing that I didn’t know is that "Why Does Love Got to Be So Sad?" was by Derek, as opposed to Eric. It sounds like a preview of “461 Ocean Boulevard” (specifically, “Motherless Children”).

    Finally, of course, there’s the title track. Many would say that it’s Clapton’s greatest song. It’s about time that Eric compensated Rita Coolidge, don’t you think? He can certainly afford it. I absolutely agree with the first commenter, “.” – the “Unplugged” version is a travesty.

    The “Crossroads” boxed set contains a bunch of other Dominos stuff, most of which was released again on the 40th anniversary set. Those included the five tracks from the aborted second album; the “Roll It Over”/”Tell the Truth” single; a live “Key to the Highway” that’s better, and shorter, than the studio version; and a duet by Duane and Eric on the old blues “Mean Old World”. It sounds more like the Allmans than the Dominos to me. It also sounds, again, like it could be a Fleetwood Mac track – this time, from their earliest days, when Peter Green was in charge. The box also contains a remix of “Layla”. The consensus among fans seems to be that this mix is atrocious. I agree. All the analog warmth of the original was taken away. Nice try, Bill Levenson, but you should have left well enough alone.

    The band was on fire here, but they paid the cost. Clapton’s addiction burned that fire out. When he recovered two personae emerged – the pop-rocker and the bluesman. They didn’t always sit alongside comfortably. I suppose that was for the best. That fire consumed his rhythm section and almost consumed him. There was no way the Dominos could have continued at this intensity. Eric would never be the same, or as consistent. At least he did provide a chunk of good material later.

    ReplyDelete