:format(jpeg):mode_rgb():quality(90)/discogs-images/R-21066925-1638699876-2227.jpeg.jpg)
Each of these projects were usually accompanied by PR activities, press blurbs, the occasional TV interview, and subsequent speculation as to how much he was in control of his own life compared to the protective net around him. That has continued with the release of At My Piano, which purports to be “his classic hits reimagined for solo piano.” Such a description conjures expectations of Brian doing a living room gig, as seen in various YouTube videos posted throughout the Covid lockdowns. His approach there, as it has been for decades, is to pound out chords and basslines rhythm-style, not the New Age approach heard on the album itself. So is it really Brian playing so prettily?
Despite our initial skepticism, we say yes, and it’s lovely. While the playing is more intricate than usual, what likely happened is that he played the chords, then overdubbed the melodies, harmonies, and counterpoints that have become so recognizable over the decades afterwards. In other words, he crafted these tracks just like he crafted all those Beach Boys classics in the first place, only doing the parts by himself rather than with a Gold Star Studio full of the Wrecking Crew. (Of course, if he really is playing all those parts live in one take, even better. But that would mean he has six hands.)
The selections are a mostly predictable grab bag of classics from the band’s heyday, beginning with the prettier ones, like “God Only Knows”, “In My Room”, and “The Warmth Of The Sun”, highlighting just how different these songs were from the standard pop songs of the time. “Wouldn’t It Be Nice”, “You Still Believe In Me”, and “I Just Wasn’t Made For These Times” provide a Pet Sounds transition to “Sketches Of Smile”, a mini-suite incorporating “Our Prayer”, “Heroes And Villains”, and “Wonderful” before a full-fledged “Surf’s Up”. “Friends” is revealed to be something of an Erik Satie homage, while “Mt. Vernon Farewell” is rescued from the suite appended to Holland. Unfortunately, having “Good Vibrations” crash in after that is just wrong.
Despite that, as we said, At My Piano is just lovely, and something about the softness of the performance and the mix make it ideal for the holiday season. Without intending to, Brian Wilson made a Christmas album. Nice of him.
Brian Wilson At My Piano (2021)—4
It’s like hearing piano demos of the songs. That isn’t a bad thing. For the most part, there isn’t a lot of up-tempo energy, except for “Good Vibrations”. It can be soothing, or boring, depending on what your mindset is at the time. It’s also tempting to sing along, of course.
ReplyDeleteI do agree that overdubbing had to be involved, most obviously with “Wouldn’t It Be Nice?” and “Good Vibrations”. My favorite is “Sketches of ‘Smile’ “. I also hear riffs from “I’m in Great Shape”, “Song for Children” and, of course, “Surf’s Up” in there. It’s fitting that Universal chose to release this on their Decca label. Nowadays, that label is usually reserved for classical music. An acknowledgment that Brian ranks up there with the masters.
“Mt. Vernon, Farewell” (Mt. Vernon being the street where Mike Love grew up) is especially sad, now that Brian has made his own final farewell. This album will always make me feel melancholy whenever I hear it. R.I.P., Brian.