Given his higher profile from the Rolling Thunder Revue and the success of his Cardiff Rose album, one might think Roger McGuinn would build on that momentum. Well, he didn’t. He put together a touring band dubbed Thunderbyrd, named after the two most direct connotations of his brand. It was also the title of his next album, another mix of covers and cowrites with Jacques Levy. While “All Night Long” has a gentle, dreamy opening, the chorus crashes in for a reach at arena rock—and sure enough, it’s a Peter Frampton cover, only a year after he Came Alive. “It’s Gone” has a little of that trademark Rickenbacker, but is drowned out by the mix, just as “Dixie Highway” is a fairly pedestrian driving song with the barest hook. As much as Tom Petty’s “American Girl” sounded like the Byrds to many people, Roger unfortunately takes the energy out of it, even at the same tempo, changing some of the words and blowing the phrasing. Tom Scott’s sax solo doesn’t do any favors either. “We Can Do It All Over Again” is a collaboration between white blues legend Barry Goldberg and the guy who wrote “Drift Away”, and a somewhat cloying plea to stand by this constantly working musician.
Continuing the journey through the history of American music, “Why Baby Why” is a cover of George Jones’ first hit single, with prominent steel guitar over a honky-tonk backing. “I’m Not Lonely Anymore” isn’t completely convincing, especially when he says he can “sing like a bird”, and the electric piano reminds you it was the late ‘70s. “Golden Loom” is the album’s token Dylan cover, this one a Desire outtake, dominated by Rick Vito’s bluesy harmonica and not very Dylanesque at all. But the song that nearly all that has gone before is the closing “Russian Hill”, a reverie on lost love, lost youth, lost everything, with its poetic lyrics given a sympathetic backing—or to put it another way, restraint. And unlike the bulk of the album, you can actually understand the words.
Thunderbyrd would benefit from more musical variety like that. Instead, it’s a grab bag of styles assaulted by a band trying to get attention in a loud bar. If you listen closely enough, you can almost hear the potential.
Roger McGuinn Thunderbyrd (1977)—2½
The interesting thing about Thunderbyrd the band was that this was the second group with that name. The first, with James Quill Smith, Bruce Barlow and Lance Dickerson, was an excellent, if low-key group, with a very clear country-rock bent, that McGuinn seemingly didn't want to follow. Roger felt that "those guys wouldn't cut it in the studio", so he replaced them with all these slick mainstream rock guys like Rick Vito, Greg Thomas and Charlie Harrison, and this is what we got. I think it's fair to say Rog made the wrong choice, kind of a pattern for him throughout the Seventies, "Cardiff Rose" excluded...
ReplyDeleteIf you want to hear the first, countryfied Thunderbyrd doing better material, you can do so here:
ReplyDeletehttps://onebuckrecords.blogspot.com/2024/12/jolly-roger-and-his-band-of-merry.html